Posts

ISDA consultation on ICE Swap Rate fallback

 ISDA has published a consultation on the fallback for ICE Swap rates . The situation related to ICE swap rates is complex and no trivial solution exists. But this situation was predictable and has been predicted for several years. The issues under discussions where already present in my first answer to ISDA consultations in 2018. The proposals in the ISDA consultations are based on approximate spread for GBP and USD LIBOR swap rates versus OIS rates. Those approximations have been proposed by the Sterling working group and ARRC. Some approximations are necessary due to the early decision taken by ISDA and regulators on the transition. Unfortunately the working papers proposed by the working groups hide significant issues and do not propose a balanced analysis of the problem. From public documents available one can infer that the working groups had information indicating that their working papers did not provide all relevant information and did not include them. At ISDA's request, ...

Monthly volume: SOFR, ESTR and SARON - June 2021

Image
This time I have also included the CHF figures. I will start there. The year-to-date (YTD) figures at LCH are LIBOR IRS at 1,670 bn and SARON OIS at 505 bn. LIBOR swaps represent still more than 75% of the notional (we have not included the FRA in the LIBOR part). Unfortunately PV01 figures are not available on LCH site, but one can guess that they would be worst for SARON. From the ISDA Clarus RFR adoption indicator (May 2021 as the June one is not available yet), it seems that globally the portion of SARON is below 15%. (*) Note that LCH has changed his volume report, with volume below 2Y as one bucket (instead of 2: <1Y and 1Y-2Y) and volume above 5Y as 3 buckets. In USD, the SOFR usage is increasing steadily but is still at relatively low levels. Over the month of June, 2,179 bn have been cleared at LCH; an increase of 23% form the previous record level in April. But the SOFR figures are still well below the LIBOR or even the Fed Funds levels. YTD, the LIBOR swap level at LCH...

Monthly volume for SOFR and ESTR: May

Image
Monthly review of ESTR and SOFR volumes. No progress in SOFR, no progress in ESTR. In May, the LCH SOFR volumes are barely above 70% of the April's ones. In volume, SOFR swaps are still below 3% of LIBOR swaps according to ISDA figures. With the decision by CCPs to steer away from ISDA's fallback and convert LIBOR swaps to OIS with spread, one could argue that LIBOR swaps and SOFR-OIS are the same products. Nevertheless given the uncertainty on the exact conversion mechanism and the non-fungibility due to spreads, I would be very reluctant to trade LIBOR swaps at this stage. Clearly the market majority disagrees with me and thus I'm wrong (but I don't know why)! EONIA is disappearing at the end of the year, in seven months, and the bulk of the OIS is still EONIA-linked.

Monthly volume for SOFR and ESTR: April

Image
Monthly review of ESTR and SOFR volumes. Decent progress in SOFR, no progress in ESTR. It seems that we can not get one month with increase in both. ESTR volumes decreasing with respect to March. EONIA is disappearing by 1 January 2022 with an unmanageable fallback process but the bulk of the EUR OIS volume is still in EONIA! The SOFR volume (ISDA figures based on US regulatory reporting) still indicates less than 3% SOFR/LIBOR ratio.

Monthly volume for SOFR and ESTR: March

Image
Monthly review of ESTR and SOFR volumes. Decent progress in ESTR, no progress in SOFR (opposite of last month). The ESTR swap volume over the month has jumped from 250 billions to 557 billions (USD equivalent). The SOFR volume is is slight decrease in March with respect to February. The monthly volume has decrease down to 1181 billions from 1310 billions. The ISDA figures (based on US regulatory reporting) are also stable. SOFR volumne is less than 2% of LIBOR volume.

CCP LIBOR cessation big bang: what about swaptions?

Over the last months there have been many discussion about the fallback (or more precisely the absence thereof) of cleared LIBOR swaps. The CCPs are planning another "big bang". Having been interested by astronomy since I was young, I thought there is only one "Big Bang" possible, but I'm not an expert. Maybe we should rename the LIBOR transition "bangs" as SME (Small and Medium-size Explosions). This new SME would cancel all existing LIBOR swaps before the cessation of LIBOR and create OISs with slightly modified payment dates. The solution is certainly one that I'm in favor of, having push for it by opposition to the ISDA Frankenstein-like fallback. I have suggested to my clients for many month to do something similar (see here and here ). The ISDA fallback is unmanageable from a market risk perspective as described in previous blogs: Fallback transformers: gaps and overlaps and here . Probably those public analysis have been used by CCPs to co...

Tough cookies

After some financial fictions, here is a food fiction. Following price manipulation and decrease of volume in cookies, the cookie market is going through a reform. There are always tough cookies. To deal with them, the Factory Cookie Authority (FCA) has decided to ask for more power to the parliament. The proposed power would allow the FCA to impose synthetic prices on cookie contracts. The cookie prices will be based on the flour price plus a fixed spread. The spread has been decided by the International Cookie Dealer Association (ICDA) after a public consultation answered by a less than 100 people, mostly ICDA members. The spread is a fixed number for the next 50 years and is not based on cost of other cookie ingredient, like sugar, eggs, salaries, taxes, but is based some on historical figures selected by ICDA mixing (pun intended) flour, sugar and rotten (i.e. in-arrears) eggs over different periods. Should the MPs vote for such a tough cookie power? Wouldn't that be a tough co...